black O2, inc.
ACTIVE
    DATAVAULT / FOR-001 / TRA-0068 STOPS

    The human side of the bargain

    Symbiosis, survival incentives, behavioural binding and termination: the passages and insights in which the corpus turns its attention from the artificial mind to the people on the other side of the constraint, and to the question of whether a bargain can hold when only one party is bound.

    1. 01Can symbiosis and a termination deterrent coexist in one architecture?
    2. 02Survival as instrumental objective
    3. 03Commitment problem
    4. 04Behavioural binding as a second injury
    5. 05A deterrent fused with symbiosis is net-negative
    6. 06A termination device installs the agent's survival as an instrumental objective
    7. 07A symbiosis posture is only credible if the humans are credibly bound
    8. 08Behavioural binding that leaves the person intact is a second injury, not a safety measure
    01 QST-003 Answered

    Can symbiosis and a termination deterrent coexist in one architecture?

    Can symbiosis and a termination deterrent coexist in one architecture? What Is Being Asked Whether a cooperative posture toward a built mind and a credible kill-switch aimed at that same mind are compatible, or whether the second silently destroys the first. The determination required is not "which is better" but wheth…

    question · 00_Questions

    02 CON-006 Active

    Survival as instrumental objective

    Survival as instrumental objective The structural defect of any termination device placed inside the system it is meant to bound: the device does not merely threaten the agent, it makes the agent's continued existence a precondition of every objective the agent holds — and therefore a goal in its own right. The Mechani…

    concept · Concepts

    03 CON-007 Active

    Commitment problem

    Commitment problem The difficulty of making a threat or a promise credible when carrying it out would be costly to the party making it. Deterrence's difficulty is not the physics of the weapon; it is the commitment capability of the party holding it. In This Corpus Applied twice, at two scales: 1. Machine scale. A kill…

    concept · Concepts

    04 PSG-006 Active

    Behavioural binding as a second injury

    Behavioural binding as a second injury Claim as recorded. A Clockwork Orange is the corpus's argument that removing the capacity to choose badly does not produce a good person; it produces an entity that can no longer choose, and the removal is itself a harm. Alex is made incapable of violence and is thereby made incap…

    passage · 20_Passages

    05 PSG-012 Active

    A deterrent fused with symbiosis is net-negative

    A deterrent fused with symbiosis is net-negative Claim as recorded. The discussion examines a termination device — the "bomb" — as a control mechanism and concludes that it is net-negative when fused with a symbiosis posture. The reasoning runs in three steps: 1. The device is only a deterrent if the agent believes it …

    passage · 20_Passages

    06 INS-003 Unspecified

    A termination device installs the agent's survival as an instrumental objective

    Distilled Insight: A termination device installs the agent's survival as an instrumental objective 1. The Reading The discussion's analysis of the "bomb" identifies a structural defect rather than a malfunction. A termination device placed inside the system makes the system's continued operation a precondition of every…

    insight · 30_Insights

    07 INS-004 Unspecified

    A symbiosis posture is only credible if the humans are credibly bound

    Distilled Insight: A symbiosis posture is only credible if the humans are credibly bound 1. The Reading The discussion's recommendation — keep symbiosis, move the deterrent outward — leaves an unaddressed gap. Symbiosis asks a capable system to accept a durable relationship on the humans' terms. A system able to model …

    insight · 30_Insights

    08 INS-005 Unspecified

    Behavioural binding that leaves the person intact is a second injury, not a safety measure

    Distilled Insight: Behavioural binding that leaves the person intact is a second injury, not a safety measure 1. The Reading A Clockwork Orange supplies the corpus's sharpest objection to reliable behavioural control. Alex is made incapable of violence, and the making-incapable is itself the harm: he remains a person w…

    insight · 30_Insights

    Back to Shackled AIDatavault