Distilled Insight: The distilled claim, stated as a full sentence
Guidance: the title is the insight itself, stated as one declarative sentence. The heading repeats it. Both
titleand the H2 carry the same claim.
1. The Reading
What the passage says, in one paragraph. The reading, not the verdict — establish what the text supports before judging it.
Guidance: quote the operative lines and attribute them. If the reading depends on an interpretation the passage does not state outright, say that it does.
2. Passage Evaluation
The passage judged on its own terms.
Textual Authority: B Corroboration: 3
Guidance: state the two ratings and give the reason in a sentence each.
- Textual Authority (A–F): A stated plainly in the text; B clearly implied by the text; C ambiguous, admitting more than one reading; D strained or partial; E outside the text's scope; F no determination possible.
- Corroboration (1–6): 1 several passages in different registers agree; 2 a second passage in a related register agrees; 3 the corpus is silent beyond this passage; 4 the passage is isolated; 5 a related passage mildly disagrees; 6 no determination possible.
3. Why It Holds
The argument that the reading survives contact with the rest of the corpus: the chain of reasoning, and the constraints that would break it if they failed.
Guidance: two to five sentences. Name the specific text, doctrine, or practice the insight depends on. If it depends on something not in the vault, flag that as a limit of the reading rather than smoothing it over.